30 Vacation Property Managers in St. Augustine, FL, USA

Comparent recognizes the top-performing vacation rental management companies in each major market. These companies have been awarded our prestigious Market Leader badge for their exceptional service, performance, and guest and owner satisfaction. This badge serves as a testament to their excellence and commitment to providing top-tier vacation rental management. Browse our list of the best companies in each market. Click here to learn more.

Discover the top short-term vacation rental property managers in St. Augustine, FL, USA. Use the list below to find and compare the top property managers for your Airbnb property.

Hide Market Overview Market Overview

Average Review Scores

4.99

Owner's Rating

4.72

4.57

4.38

Airbnb Metrics

514

Properties

$283.27

Average Annual Daily Rate

31.91%

Average Occupancy

Houses

Condos

Other Properties

1 Bedroom

2 Bedrooms

3 Bedrooms

4 Bedrooms

5 Bedrooms

6+ Bedrooms

These metrics are reflected with the listings that are currently on Comparent

Vrbo Metrics

341

Properties

$311.00

Average Annual Daily Rate

32.71%

Average Occupancy

Houses

Condos

Other Properties

1 Bedroom

2 Bedrooms

3 Bedrooms

4 Bedrooms

5 Bedrooms

6+ Bedrooms

These metrics are reflected with the listings that are currently on Comparent

Market Leaders

Saint Augustine

St Augustine

St. Augustine

& Above

Market Leaders

Saint Augustine

St Augustine

St. Augustine

Owner Ratings

& Above

Discover your property's true value

Get 5+ customized rental projections from your chosen property managers

Founded In 2019

Joseph Ellen Properties, LLC

Headquarters Jacksonville, Florida

Employees 10

Owner Rating 5.0 (24)

4.7 (4607)

4.6 (791)

4.8 (218)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Owner Rating 5.0 (24)

4.7 (4607)

4.6 (791)

4.8 (218)

Joseph Ellen Properties is a local boutique vacation rental management company that exists to create outstanding experiences for our guests & our property owners. We are leveling up the industry by re-defining the way short term rental... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Founded In 2017

Unwind Luxury Vacations

Manages 108 properties, 1 in St Augustine

Headquarters Little Rock, Arkansas

Employees 16

4.6 (979)

4.5 (549)

4.6 (463)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

4.6 (979)

4.5 (549)

4.6 (463)

Unwind is a property management company for luxury short term rentals in the United States. Our mission is to create trusting relationships with our owners and first-rate travel experiences for our guests. Our company is designed to ta... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Founded In 2017

Suncastle Properties of Ponte Vedra Beach

Headquarters Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

Employees 7

4.5 (323)

4.3 (287)

4.1 (51)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

4.5 (323)

4.3 (287)

4.1 (51)

We are Mark and Matt Odekirk, Principals of Suncastle Properties. As a full-service Real Estate, Vacation Rental and Property Management firm located in Ponte Vedra Beach, we've made it our business to provide an engaged, hands-on... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Opulent Property Management

Headquarters Jacksonville Beach, Florida

4.6 (908)

4.9 (269)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

4.6 (908)

4.9 (269)

As a locally owned and operated management company with over a decade of experience in the luxury vacation home industry, we take pride in being a family-owned and run business. Our commitment to excellence is reflected in our hands-on... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Checkmate Rentals

Headquarters Pennsylvania

4.9 (362)

4.9 (73)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

4.9 (362)

4.9 (73)

Checkmate Rentals changes the way you get to enjoy your vacation homes. With our professional, local caretaking teams in every market we manage, central support staff, and 24/7 customer service, we’ll be there every step of the way.W... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Need help choosing?

Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk To An Advisor

Founded In 2001

CondoRental.com

Headquarters Saint Augustine, Florida

Employees 8

4.3 (620)

3.3 (3)

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

4.3 (620)

3.3 (3)

CondoRental.com is a full-service property management company and provides friendly, professional service to St. Augustine, Florida vacationing guests and homeowners. We offer an array of turn-key accommodations ranging from cozy beach... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Ancient City Hideaways

Headquarters St. Augustine, Florida

Sponsored

VERIFIED

Sponsored

VERIFIED

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Founded In 2022

Portoro

Manages 154 properties, 62 in St Augustine

Headquarters South Carolina

Employees 23

Owner Rating 5.0 (1)

4.9 (2750)

4.5 (48)

4.5 (12)

VERIFIED

Owner Rating 5.0 (1)

4.9 (2750)

4.5 (48)

4.5 (12)

Portoro is your partner for premium, white-glove property management. We only manage the top homes in our markets because our focus is on a high-touch, customizable solution that drives above-market revenues and keeps your home pristin... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Founded In 2019

Nomad Hospitality

Manages 114 properties, 4 in St Augustine

Headquarters Jacksonville Beach, Florida

Employees 12

VERIFIED

Hi! We are Jered & Carly and Josh & Kass. We are two families who built a Jacksonville-based hospitality company focused on providing quality accommodations with thoughtful design. But we don’t run everything ourselves - we have a te... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Founded In 2022

B&B Coastal Properties

Headquarters Palm Coast, Florida

Employees 2

VERIFIED

We are a boutique short-term rental property management company in Palm Coast, Florida. Our personalized approach, innovative marketing, exceptional customer service, experienced team, and transparent reporting set us apart. We help ho... View full profile

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile

Need help choosing?

Schedule a free 15-minute call with a Comparent expert to find the best vacation rental managers for you.

Talk To An Advisor

Founded In 2019

Equity Excelerator

Headquarters St Augustine, Florida

VERIFIED

For owners. By owners. We deliver market-defying occupancy rates alongside magnificent cleanings. In short, we were investment property owners first and investment property managers second.

View Profile

Compare

NEW

Get Rental Projection

NEW

Save

View Profile